Home Repair
How to Fix a Water Heater (No Hot Water, Leaking, Pilot Light)
Troubleshoot a tank water heater by symptom — no hot water, lukewarm water, leaks and a pilot that won't stay lit — with safe fixes and clear signs it's time to call a pro.
When the shower suddenly runs cold, the water heater usually has one of a handful of problems — and most of them announce themselves clearly. This guide walks through tank-style gas and electric heaters by symptom, so you can figure out what's wrong, fix the simple things yourself, and know when to stop and call a pro.
Before you start, find the rating plate and the lighting instructions printed on the side of the tank. Every heater is a little different, and that label is the authority for your model.
Symptom, likely cause and fix
| Symptom | Likely cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| No hot water (gas) | Pilot out, thermocouple failing, gas valve closed | Relight per the label; check or replace the thermocouple; open the gas supply |
| No hot water (electric) | Tripped breaker, tripped high-limit reset, failed upper element | Reset breaker; press the red reset button; test elements with power off |
| Hot water runs out quickly | Failed lower element (electric), sediment, broken dip tube | Test the lower element; flush the tank; have a plumber check the dip tube |
| Water too hot | Thermostat set too high or stuck | Lower to about 120°F; if it stays too hot, replace the thermostat or call a pro |
| Pilot won't stay lit | Dirty or failed thermocouple, poor gas supply | Clean or replace the thermocouple; call a gas tech if it still fails |
| Popping or rumbling | Sediment buildup on the tank bottom | Flush the tank following the manufacturer's directions |
| Rotten-egg smell in hot water only | Bacteria reacting with the anode rod | Flush and disinfect; ask a plumber about a different anode rod |
| Water at the T&P valve | High pressure, high temperature, or a failing valve | Don't cap it; have a plumber check pressure and thermal expansion |
| Drip from drain valve | Valve not fully closed or worn | Close fully, add a brass hose cap, or replace the valve |
| Water seeping from the tank | Tank corrosion | Replace the water heater |
The fixes in the steps below cover the most common DIY repairs. If you need a meter for testing electric elements, see our guide to the best multimeters — a basic model that reads ohms is all you need.
A note on flushing
Sediment from hard water settles in the bottom of the tank, causing popping noises, slower heating and, over time, shorter tank life. Many manufacturers recommend draining a few gallons — or flushing the tank — about once a year. Turn the heater off or to pilot first, use a hose to a floor drain or outside, and expect the water to be hot. On an older tank that has never been flushed, an old drain valve may not reseal well afterwards, so have a cap or a replacement valve on hand.
Related jobs
Chasing high water bills? A toilet that runs all day can waste more water than a slow leak — here's how to fix a running toilet. If hot water runs out too fast, a lower-flow head helps; see how to replace a shower head.
Step by step
- 1
Identify your heater and read its label
Find the rating plate and the lighting/operating instructions on the tank. Note whether it's gas or electric, the voltage and element wattage (electric), and the model number. The label's instructions override anything general — including this guide.
- 2
Check the obvious first
Look at the thermostat or gas control setting — someone may have turned it to vacation or pilot. For electric heaters, check the breaker (usually a double-pole 240V breaker). For gas heaters, make sure the gas supply valve to the heater is open (handle parallel with the pipe).
- 3
Gas: check whether the pilot is lit
Look through the sight glass near the bottom of the tank. No flame means the pilot is out. Many newer gas heaters have a status light on the gas control that blinks a diagnostic code — look the pattern up in your manual before doing anything else.
- 4
Gas: relight the pilot following the label exactly
Turn the control to OFF and wait the time the label specifies (often several minutes) so gas can clear. Then follow the label's sequence: usually set to PILOT, hold the knob down, press the igniter, and keep holding for the stated time before releasing and turning to ON. Never relight if you smell gas.
- 5
Gas: diagnose a pilot that won't stay lit
If the pilot lights but goes out when you release the knob, the thermocouple (or flame sensor) is the usual suspect — it may be dirty, loose, or failed. Make sure it sits in the pilot flame and its connection at the gas control is snug. Replacing it is a common DIY fix on older open-burner heaters; on sealed-combustion (FVIR) heaters, or if the gas control valve itself is faulty, call a licensed gas technician.
- 6
Electric: shut off power and confirm it's off
Switch off the heater's breaker. Remove the upper access panel and fold back the insulation, keeping fingers clear of the terminals. Use a non-contact voltage tester on the wires at the thermostat to confirm there is no power before touching anything.
- 7
Electric: press the high-limit reset button
Above the upper thermostat is a red reset button (the high-limit or ECO switch). Press it firmly — a click means it had tripped. Replace insulation and the panel, restore power and wait an hour. If it trips again, a thermostat or element is likely stuck on, so keep troubleshooting or call a pro.
- 8
Electric: test the heating elements with a multimeter
With the breaker off and power confirmed off, disconnect one wire from an element and set your multimeter to ohms. Touch the probes to the two element screws: a reading of roughly 10–30 ohms (depending on wattage) is normal, while no reading at all means the element is burned out. Then test from each screw to the metal mounting flange — any reading there means the element is shorted to the tank and should be replaced.
- 9
Electric: replace a failed element
Close the cold water supply, open a hot tap, and drain the tank below the element using a hose on the drain valve. Unscrew the element with an element wrench, install the new one with a new gasket, and refill the tank completely — run a hot tap until it flows steadily with no air — before restoring power. Powering a dry element destroys it in seconds.
- 10
Find the source of any leak
Dry everything with a towel and watch. Drips from the top usually come from the water connections or the T&P valve; drips at the bottom may be the drain valve, condensation on a gas heater, or water running down from above. Water seeping from the tank itself or rust-stained puddles under the heater point to a failed tank.
- 11
Fix fitting, drain valve and T&P leaks
Snug a leaking supply connection a quarter turn at a time without overtightening. A dripping drain valve can often be stopped by closing it fully and fitting a brass hose cap, or by replacing the valve. If the T&P valve is discharging, don't cap or plug it — the cause may be excess temperature or pressure, so call a plumber to check pressure and thermal expansion before replacing the valve.
- 12
Restore and test
Turn the water supply, gas or power back on per the label. Set the thermostat to about 120°F, wait an hour or so for the tank to recover, then check a hot tap and look again for leaks around everything you touched.
Common mistakes
- Relighting a pilot right after it goes out without waiting the time on the label for gas to clear.
- Capping, plugging or removing the T&P valve or its discharge pipe to stop a drip — that valve is what keeps the tank from becoming dangerous.
- Testing elements or thermostats with the breaker on, or trusting the breaker label without checking with a voltage tester.
- Restoring power to an electric heater before the tank is completely full, which burns out a new element instantly.
- Cranking the thermostat up to fix lukewarm water and creating a scald risk instead of finding the real cause.
- Trying to patch a leaking tank — once the tank itself leaks, it needs replacing.
Frequently asked questions
Why do I have no hot water at all?
On a gas heater, the most common causes are a pilot that went out, a failing thermocouple, or a closed gas valve. On an electric heater, check for a tripped breaker, a tripped high-limit reset button, or a burned-out upper element, which stops the whole tank from heating.
Why does my hot water run out so fast?
On an electric heater, a failed lower element is the classic cause — the top of the tank still heats, but there's only a fraction of the usual hot water. Other causes include heavy sediment, a broken dip tube, a thermostat set too low, or a tank that's simply too small for your household.
Is a leaking water heater an emergency?
A drip from a fitting or drain valve is a repair you can schedule. Water coming from the tank itself, or a T&P valve that keeps discharging, needs prompt attention. Turn off the cold supply and the power or gas, and call a plumber.
What temperature should a water heater be set to?
About 120°F is the common recommendation for homes — hot enough for everyday use while lowering scald risk. Water at higher settings can burn skin within seconds, which matters most for young children and older adults.
When should I call a professional instead of fixing it myself?
Call a licensed plumber or gas technician if you smell gas, the gas control valve or burner needs work, the T&P valve keeps opening, the tank is leaking, or you're not comfortable working around 240V wiring. Many areas also require a permit for water heater replacement.
Related guides
- GuideHow to Replace a Garbage DisposalSwap out a dead or leaking garbage disposal in an afternoon: cut the power, remove the old unit, wire the new one, seat the mounting ring and leak-test everything.
- GuideHow to Remove a Sink Drain (Bathroom and Kitchen)Remove a bathroom pop-up drain or a kitchen basket strainer step by step: stopper, pivot rod, P-trap, locknut and flange — plus how to reinstall it without leaks.
- GuideHow to Install a BathtubAn honest walkthrough of installing an alcove bathtub: removing the old tub, checking the subfloor, setting a ledger and mortar bed, connecting the drain and overflow, and waterproofing.