Home Repair
How to Replace a Toilet
Pull out an old toilet and set a new one without leaks: measure the rough-in, inspect the flange, choose a wax or wax-free seal, and tighten everything just enough.
Replacing a toilet sounds like a big plumbing job, but the toilet itself is held down by just two bolts and sealed with a ring of wax or foam. If you can lift about 60 to 100 pounds of porcelain (in pieces, ideally) and turn a wrench gently, you can do this in an afternoon.
The parts of the job that matter most happen before the new toilet goes in: buying one that fits, and making sure the flange it sits on is sound.
Measure before you buy
The rough-in is the distance from the finished wall to the center of the drain, and you measure it at the closet bolts. A 12-inch rough-in is by far the most common, but 10- and 14-inch drains turn up in older homes and tight bathrooms. A toilet built for a shorter rough-in will leave a gap behind the tank; one built for a longer rough-in won't fit at all.
While the tape is out, note the bowl shape you want (round or elongated) and check that an elongated bowl won't block a door. Our toilet roundup covers flush performance, bowl height and water use.
Reading the flange
The closet flange is the round fitting on the floor that the toilet bolts to. Once the old toilet is out, look at it closely.
| What you see | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Flange flush with or a little above the finished floor, solid and uncracked | Good condition | Clean it and use a standard seal |
| Flange sits below the finished floor (common after new tile) | Recessed flange | Add a flange spacer, or use a thicker or wax-free seal made for recessed flanges |
| One bolt slot is broken or the rim is cracked | Damaged flange | Install a metal repair ring or bolt-slot repair plate over it |
| Flange moves, or the floor around it is soft or stained | Loose flange or water damage | Stop and call a plumber; the subfloor may need repair |
Wax ring vs. wax-free seal
A wax ring is the traditional choice. It's cheap and reliable, but it molds to the toilet once and can't be reused if you have to lift the bowl. Wax rings with a plastic horn help guide waste into the drain.
A wax-free seal uses foam or rubber. You can reposition the toilet without ruining it, it's less messy, and it handles a slightly low flange better than a standard wax ring. Some plumbers still prefer wax; either is fine as long as you follow the instructions on the package. See our roundup of toilet seals for both types.
Don't overtighten
The most common way to ruin a new toilet is a wrench. Porcelain doesn't flex, so tightening closet bolts or tank bolts past snug can crack the base or the tank, sometimes hours later. Alternate sides a little at a time, stop when the toilet doesn't move, and use shims rather than bolt pressure to stop any rocking.
If a slow drip shows up at the supply line, tighten it a quarter turn at a time. If water appears at the base after flushing, the seal didn't seat; shut off the water, lift the toilet and start again with a new seal.
Step by step
- 1
Measure the rough-in
Measure from the finished wall behind the toilet (not the baseboard) to the center of the closet bolts on the floor. Most homes are 12 inches; older houses may be 10 or 14. Buy a toilet that matches this number or it won't fit against the wall.
- 2
Shut off the water and empty the toilet
Turn the shutoff valve behind the toilet clockwise until it stops. Hold the handle down to flush and drain the tank, then sponge or vacuum the remaining water out of the tank and bowl.
- 3
Disconnect the supply line
Keep a towel under the valve and unscrew the supply line where it meets the tank. If the valve weeps or won't fully close, replace it before you go further.
- 4
Unbolt and lift out the old toilet
Pop the caps off the closet bolts and remove the nuts. If they spin or are rusted, cut them with a mini hacksaw. Rock the toilet gently side to side to break the wax seal, then lift it straight up and set it on a towel or cardboard. Keep it upright so water doesn't spill out of the trap.
- 5
Plug the drain and scrape the old seal
Stuff a rag into the drain opening to block sewer gas and stop small parts from falling in. Scrape every bit of old wax off the flange and floor with a putty knife, then wipe the area clean.
- 6
Inspect the flange
The flange should be screwed firmly to the floor, uncracked, and ideally sitting flush with or slightly above the finished floor. Repair a broken bolt slot or cracked rim with a repair ring. If the flange sits below the floor surface, add a spacer or use a thicker seal designed for recessed flanges.
- 7
Set the bolts and the seal
Slide new closet bolts into the flange slots so they sit parallel to the wall. Press a wax ring onto the toilet's outlet horn (or onto the flange, per its instructions), or fit a wax-free seal the way its maker directs. Remove the rag from the drain now.
- 8
Lower the toilet onto the flange
Lift the bowl, line its bolt holes up with the bolts, and lower it straight down in one motion. Press down firmly with your body weight, rocking very slightly, until the base sits on the floor. With wax, don't lift it again — a disturbed wax ring should be replaced.
- 9
Level the bowl and tighten the closet bolts
Check the rim with a level and slide plastic shims under the base wherever it rocks. Add washers and nuts and tighten them a little at a time, alternating sides. Stop at snug plus a small turn: overtightening cracks porcelain. Trim the bolts above the nuts and snap on the caps.
- 10
Install the tank (two-piece toilets)
If your toilet ships in two pieces, set the tank gasket on the flush valve, lower the tank onto the bowl and tighten the tank bolts by hand, then alternately with a wrench until the tank sits level and doesn't move. Again, stop as soon as it's firm.
- 11
Connect a new supply line
Thread a new braided supply line onto the tank fill valve hand-tight, then connect the other end to the shutoff valve and snug it with a wrench. Plastic nuts on the tank side only need a hand-tight turn.
- 12
Turn on the water and check for leaks
Open the shutoff valve slowly and let the tank fill. Check the supply connections and tank bolts with a dry paper towel, then flush several times and look around the base. Recheck the next day before you caulk the base, if you choose to.
Common mistakes
- Buying a toilet before measuring the rough-in, then finding it won't fit against the wall.
- Forgetting to pull the rag out of the drain before setting the toilet.
- Cranking down closet bolts or tank bolts until the porcelain cracks — snug is enough.
- Lifting and re-setting the toilet on the same wax ring, which breaks the seal.
- Reusing an old, kinked or corroded supply line instead of spending a few dollars on a new one.
- Ignoring a broken or low flange, which leads to a rocking toilet and slow leaks under the floor.
Frequently asked questions
Wax ring or wax-free seal: which is better?
Both work when installed correctly. A wax ring is inexpensive and proven but is one-shot — if you lift the toilet, replace it. A wax-free foam or rubber seal can be repositioned, isn't affected by temperature, and is handy when the flange sits slightly below the floor. Follow the seal maker's instructions either way.
How do I know my toilet's rough-in size?
Measure from the finished wall to the center of the closet bolts holding the toilet down. If there are two pairs of bolts, measure to the rear pair. The result will usually be close to 10, 12 or 14 inches.
Should I caulk around the base of the toilet?
Many plumbers do, and some local codes require it. A common approach is to caulk the front and sides and leave a small gap at the back so a future leak shows up on the floor instead of hiding under it. Check your local code and the toilet's instructions.
Why does my new toilet rock?
The floor is uneven or the flange sits too high. Slide plastic shims under the base until it's solid, then trim them flush. Never rely on tightening the bolts to stop a rock — that's how bowls crack.
When should I call a plumber?
Call one if the flange is rotted or broken beyond a repair ring, the subfloor around it is soft, the shutoff valve won't close, or the drain line itself is cracked. Those problems need more than a toilet swap.
Related guides
- GuideHow to Fix a Running ToiletFind out why your toilet keeps running — flapper, chain, float, fill valve or overflow tube — with a simple food-coloring test, then replace the flapper or fill valve yourself.
- GuideHow to Unclog a ToiletStop the overflow, then clear a clogged toilet with a flange plunger, dish soap and hot water, or a closet auger — and what never to pour or push into the bowl.
- GuideHow to Install a BathtubAn honest walkthrough of installing an alcove bathtub: removing the old tub, checking the subfloor, setting a ledger and mortar bed, connecting the drain and overflow, and waterproofing.